Remember March 2012, when the Indianapolis Colts released Peyton Manning and teams around the league lined up to figure out whether his surgically repaired neck could still hold up? But when the San Francisco 49ers entered the picture, they did so differently. Instead of a public pursuit, head coach Jim Harbaugh and offensive coordinator Greg Roman opted to arrange a workout in North Carolina with an unusual level of discretion. And now, it’s the one that’s standing out precisely because it wanted to stay so out of sight.

“Back in 2012, I was in shock that I was a free agent,” Manning recalled in his interview with ESPN. “The 49ers came down to North Carolina. I was at Duke, and Harbaugh and Greg Roman came down and were very CIA-like. They flew into another town because they didn’t want to get tracked by Adam Schefter or Chris Mortensen. Harbaugh had a hoodie on, Bill Belichick style, at the workout in case Mort was in a tree.”

That meeting came days after the Indianapolis Colts made a decision that had been looming for months. On March 7, 2012, owner Jim Irsay released Peyton Manning following a season he never played, four neck surgeries, and a contract that included a looming $28 million option bonus. Indianapolis held the first overall pick in the draft and faced severe salary-cap constraints, and even as Irsay explored last-minute restructuring options, the numbers and the uncertainty around Manning’s health left no workable path forward.

Just months earlier, Manning had signed a five-year, $90 million deal with the expectation that he would finish his career in Indianapolis. But after a 2–14 collapse without him in 2011 and the chance to reset the roster around a new quarterback, the Colts chose to move on.

Teams like the Tennessee Titans, Arizona Cardinals, Miami Dolphins, and the Denver Broncos openly entered the race. The 49ers, though, stayed quiet, and that was intentional. Harbaugh was already working behind the scenes. As it turned out, Harbaugh and Roman met Manning at the North Carolina home of former Duke and Tennessee head coach David Cutcliffe.

Cutcliffe’s home wasn’t incidental. Manning trusted him, and Duke’s private facilities allowed for controlled workouts at a time when Manning’s throwing sessions were being closely monitored across the league. Unlike public college facilities, access required clearance, which reduced the risk of reporters or rival evaluators showing up unannounced. 

 Harbaugh and Roman wanted to see Manning throw in person and gauge his arm strength themselves rather than rely solely on medical reports or secondhand assessments. Harbaugh even asked to play catch during the session, wanting to feel the velocity and touch firsthand as questions about Manning’s post-surgery strength dominated league conversations. 

The timing made discretion necessary. Manning was the most accomplished quarterback ever to reach free agency, but he was also a financial and medical gamble. San Francisco, meanwhile, was coming off a 13–3 year and an NFC Championship Game appearance. This was a roster built to contend immediately, which raised the stakes of getting the decision right.

But afterward, Manning continued working out with other teams. Reports suggested the Titans even offered him a higher annual salary. But ultimately, his decision for the 2012 season came down to two teams: the 49ers and the Broncos.

Manning ultimately chose Denver, calling it a “great fit” based on his comfort with the staff, the offensive discussions, and a strong connection with executive vice president of football operations John Elway. He signed a five-year, $96 million deal, and while the paths diverged, the comeback was clear. The 49ers reached the Super Bowl that season but lost to the Baltimore Ravens, while Manning won NFL Comeback Player of the Year in 2012 after throwing for over 4,500 yards and 11 touchdowns, later returning to the Super Bowl and closing his career with a Super Bowl 50 victory over the Carolina Panthers. 

Through it all, the North Carolina workout remains a telling snapshot of that time, one that, for all its discretion, still managed to include a wholesome peanut butter and jelly sandwich for Harbaugh.  

Jim Harbaugh couldn’t deny a peanut butter and jelly sandwich

Jim Harbaugh arrived at David Cutcliffe’s house in North Carolina with one goal in mind: work out with Peyton Manning. That was it. Film, throwing session, evaluation. But, as the group prepared to head out and throw, Mrs. Cutcliffe came downstairs and asked if anyone wanted something to eat. Manning and Roman politely declined. But Harbaugh didn’t.

“I remember this. We were leaving to go throw, and Mrs. Cutcliffe, who I’ve known forever, just a sweet lady, she said, ‘Would y’all like anything to eat before you go?'” Manning recalled back in 2020 in his interview with The Athletic. “It was one of those when somebody offers you, you kind of get the feel maybe she really didn’t want to make you something to eat, but she felt like she had to offer, that kind of thing.

“So I was like, ‘No, thanks, Mrs. Cutcliffe, I’m fine,’ and Greg Roman’s like, ‘I’m fine, Thank you for offering.’ And coach Cut’s like, ‘I’m fine, honey.’ And I remember Harbaugh just said, ‘Yeah, I’ll have a PB&J.”

Top Stories

Sources: John Harbaugh Wasn’t Fired, Left Ravens After Refusing Major Staff Changes

Andy Reid Fires Coach In Attempt to Rebuild Staff After Receiving HC Requests For Chiefs’ Coordinators

Three Arrested in Cleveland For Burglary at Shedeur Sanders’ Home

Mike McDaniel Contract: How Much Do Miami Dolphins Owe the Fired Coach?

Bill Cowher’s Strong Message to Steelers on Firing Mike Tomlin After HC’s Blunt Playoff Message

While Manning might have found the moment slightly awkward, Harbaugh saw it differently. For him, accepting was simply the polite thing to do.

“I always feel like, at least in my mom’s house, when she asks if you want something, she’s offended if you don’t let her make you something. I do love PB&J,” The HC noted.

Years later, all these moments stand out, not for the decision it led to, but for how carefully everything was handled during that free agency. Fast forward to now: Peyton Manning is retired, and Harbaugh has since moved on from the 49ers to lead the Los Angeles Chargers.