Bo Nickal is a prime example of wrestling royalty transitioning into the world of MMA and making the most out of it. The Penn State alum has rapidly climbed the 185lbs ladder and earned the rare honor of debuting on the main card of a UFC PPV (UFC 285). The 2019 Dan Hodge Trophy winner entered the promotion with a chip on his shoulder with many calling him the next big thing in the sport. However, his recent outing at UFC 309 has taken some of that momentum away with fans expressing more concern about his upcoming challenge.

Despite earning a win, Nickal faced criticism owing to a lackluster bout and not going for a single takedown against Paul Craig with even Dana White throwing a word of caution during the post-fight presser. “Well, you know, we’ve had these discussions with Bo, Bo needs work. Bo is an up-and-coming guy. I know he has big aspirations and wants to move faster than he should, but tonight showed that – I mean, he still dominated, he won the whole fight, but he’s got work to do. It’s alright, we’ll move him.” 

Now, Nickal faces his toughest test yet at UFC Fight Night 256 — a showdown with Reinier de Ridder. The 34-year-old former ONE Championship double champion has quickly made his mark in the UFC since joining the promotion in 2024. With back-to-back submission victories over veterans like Gerald Meerschaert and fan-favorite Kevin Holland, the Dutch Knight seems ready!

The excitement for UFC Fight Night 256 reached new heights after MMA Fighting’s Instagram outlet shared the fight lineup. Fans were particularly enthusiastic about the return of Jeremy Stephens, who hasn’t competed since his 2022 loss to Natan Schulte. With compelling matchups like Nickal vs. de Ridder and Stephens’ comeback, the event is shaping up to be a must-watch for MMA fans.

When fans saw that Bo Nickal was matched up against Reinier de Ridder, concerns quickly surfaced. Given de Ridder’s reputation as a formidable opponent, it’s understandable why some are worried about the undefeated middleweight. While this bout is a huge opportunity for de Ridder to capitalize on the hype and attention Nickal brings. In addition,  it’s also a prime chance for him to steal the spotlight. As expected, MMA fans have been vocal about the matchup — and many are expressing concern for Nickal’s undefeated record.

Fans predict a grim fate for Bo Nickal against Reinier de Ridder

Most fans are siding with ‘The Dutch Knight’. They believe Reinier de Ridder could deliver a classic ‘fraud check’ to Bo Nickal and send him to the shadow realm. One fan said, “RDR vs Bo sounds interesting. RDR not gonna get smoked like that other ppl Bo fought.” Another added, “Bo’s ground game gonna be tested fr.”

This concern is understandable. De Ridder’s dominant grappling, particularly his ability to secure submissions and his dangerous arsenal of D’Arce chokes and knee strikes from the turtle position, makes him a serious threat. While Nickal’s wrestling is top-tier, he hasn’t really showcased that inside the Octagon.

Nickal’s 63% striking accuracy could be a key factor if the fight stays on the feet. Moreover, it gives him a solid chance to land a knockout. However, de Ridder isn’t far behind with a respectable 57% striking accuracy. Moreover, with 13 submission wins to his name, he’s proven lethal once the fight hits the mat.

Fans have been vocal about the matchup. One declared, “Bo Nickal finally gonna get fraud checked.” Another bluntly stated, “Rip Bo Nickal.” Meanwhile, some were simply excited to see Nickal back in action after his November 2024 win over Paul Craig. “Finally Bo Nickal fights,” one follower wrote. Others are already predicting de Ridder’s dominance, with comments like “RDR choking bo the f–k out” and “Bo gets finished!”

Given de Ridder’s grappling prowess, it’s no surprise fans are concerned for Nickal. Interestingly, the Penn State Alum himself recognizes the challenge ahead. Speaking with Ariel Helwani before UFC 309, the undefeated 185-pounder reflected on de Ridder’s performance at UFC Vegas 100. He said, “Yeah, I watched his fight, I mean, he’s got a good record. He’s, you know, a lot stronger in the jiu-jitsu department than the striking department.”

So, will the fans be right in backing de Ridder? Or will Nickal prove his doubters wrong and keep his undefeated streak intact? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!