The New York Yankees did not impress their fans with how the postseason went for the team. After beating the Red Sox, they crashed out against the Blue Jays. When the fans looked back at the whole season, there were a few weak points the team needs to fix in the offseason. One of those points was Anthony Volpe. Although the management backs him, the fans don’t think Volpe will be the guy the Yankees can rely on.

In a podcast on WFAN Radio, Evan Roberts spoke about how he thought the Yankees would go after Alex Bregman and replace Volpe with him. He said, “Here’s what I’m going to say to Alex Bregman, you’re my shortstop this year… Here’s why this is important, Yankee fans. You need to take away the Volpe drug. He’s a drug, and you need him to take them away. If Alex Bregman is here playing shortstop… Anthony Volpe is exactly what I envision him to be, a super utility player.”

Yankees fans have begun to lose faith in Anthony Volpe as a full-time shortstop this season. His -7 outs above average ranked last among qualified shortstops, tying him with CJ Abrams and Bo Bichette. His .276 on-base percentage placed him among the least productive hitters in baseball, drawing frustration from fans. Even as boos echoed through Yankee Stadium, the team continued to publicly back their struggling infielder.

Volpe’s issues went beyond the numbers, often showing up in key defensive lapses during crucial games. His errant play against Boston, where he failed to record an out on a routine grounder, captured that concern. Despite his .454 OPS since the All-Star break, manager Aaron Boone refused to consider benching him. The Yankees remain committed to Volpe, insisting his defensive instincts outweigh the metrics that paint a harsher picture.

Alex Bregman’s free agency only intensifies that contrast. Bregman, a two-time All-Star, hit .273 with 18 home runs and a 125 wRC+ in 2025. Defensively, he logged a .973 fielding percentage and 49 double plays at shortstop, proving his reliability. As such, he would be expected to land a six-year, $180 million deal this winter. For fans, that experience and steady performance symbolize the infield balance New York has been missing with Volpe.

The Yankees can keep defending Anthony Volpe, but numbers rarely lie for long in the Bronx. Alex Bregman, meanwhile, represents everything the Yankees claim to value but haven’t found in years. If New York truly wants stability, maybe it’s time they trade loyalty for results.

The Yankees could also solve their outfield problems if they make the signing

There comes a point where even the mighty New York Yankees can’t hide their flaws behind pinstripes and nostalgia. The outfield, once a symbol of swagger and power, has turned into a revolving door of “maybe next year” candidates. So now, the Bronx brain trust is plotting a move that could finally restore order, or at least give them something to brag about again.

Kyle Schwarber’s future in Philadelphia hangs in the balance as free agency opens its doors. The Phillies want him back, but his expiring contract gives other contenders an open invitation. At 32, Schwarber’s value has soared after hitting 187 home runs across four seasons. His power numbers have put him in line for a deal exceeding the $79 million he earned in his last contract.

The New York Yankees have entered the chase, viewing Schwarber as a solution to their outfield instability. ESPN’s Jesse Rogers reported that the Bronx Bombers are a “real threat” to lure him away. His experience and left-handed power make him an ideal fit for Yankee Stadium’s short right-field porch. Yet even as the market heats up, Schwarber admits the thought of leaving Philadelphia’s clubhouse weighs heavily on him.

If the Yankees act quickly, they could finally turn their outfield from chaos into strength. Kyle Schwarber’s decision will test Philadelphia’s loyalty and the Bronx Bombers’ financial muscle simultaneously. Baseball fans everywhere will watch eagerly, hoping this next move delivers drama worthy of autumn headlines.