This offseason has more news of clubhouse toxicity than trades. If you thought the Mets were the only ones facing problems in the clubhouse, think again, because their division rivals, the Philadelphia Phillies, are not far behind. But unlike the Mets, they just traded away their problem, but some fans are not happy.

After Matt Strahm got traded away to the Royals, a YouTube fan channel, Phillies Digest, talked about how this was not a good deal to make.

“The Philadelphia Phillies made a somewhat surprising move to trade away left-handed reliever Matt Strahm,” said the host. “This is probably the worst deal that Dave Dumbrossski has done since he’s been in charge of the Phillies.”

Reports indicated Matt Strahm’s outspoken comments toward team management created tension inside Philadelphia’s clubhouse recently. Sources described repeated disagreements with coaches and front office officials over roles, usage, and communication. Those issues surfaced as Philadelphia evaluated payroll priorities and bullpen depth ahead of 2026 planning.

Strahm publicly thanked teammates and the organization afterward, acknowledging positives despite a difficult ending there.

Philadelphia traded Strahm to Kansas City for right-hander Jonathan Bowlan on December 19. The move cleared Strahm’s projected $7.5 million 2026 salary from the Phillies’ books entirely forward. Those savings were reported earmarked toward Brad Keller’s $11 million annual salary through the 2026 contract.

On the field, Strahm delivered elite results, reinforcing why the transaction unsettled many Philadelphia fans. From 2023 to 2025, he logged a 2.71 ERA with 30.5% strikeouts across 212.2 innings. In 2025 alone, Strahm posted a 2.74 ERA and 7.8% walk rate over 62.1 innings. Such production at $7.5 million contrasted sharply with reallocating funds to another reliever already signed.

Still, the separation aligns logically when viewed through age, control, and roster construction considerations overall. Kansas City gains a proven left-hander, while Philadelphia secures flexibility and a younger arm long-term.

Strahm returns to where he debuted in 2016, and the Phillies rebalance their future commitments and financial planning.

Philadelphia moved on from Matt Strahm, betting structure over comfort, and that choice will echo. Dave Dombrowski chose payroll logic and clubhouse calm, even as fans questioned competitive urgency. Kansas City gets certainty, Philadelphia gets flexibility, and the standings will decide who blinked.

The Phillies owner justifies the pitching moves the team has made this offseason

There’s a certain confidence that comes with moving money, arms, and egos all at once, and it’s usually worn by people who believe explanation equals control. This week, Philadelphia’s owner stepped forward to explain the logic, the patience, and the timing. The message was calm, rehearsed, and unmistakably firm.

The Philadelphia Phillies reshaped their bullpen this week, making three significant moves before the 2026 season begins. They traded left-handed reliever Matt Strahm to the Kansas City Royals for right-handed pitcher Jonathan Bowlan, saving about $6.7 million in salary.

They also signed right-hander Brad Keller to a two-year deal worth $22 million, highlighting confidence in his recent 2.07 ERA and 0.96 WHIP over 68 appearances. Later, the Phillies acquired left-handed reliever Kyle Backus from Arizona in exchange for outfield prospect Avery Owusu-Asiedu, adding depth to their relief corps.

Top Stories

Mark Shapiro Rubs Salt in Yankees’ Wounds as He Issues Stark Ultimatum to Blue Jays Clubhouse

Ross Atkins Warned Against Alex Bregman’s Misstep as 2 Blue Jays World Series Heroes Face Exit

Red Sox–Cubs Hit Major Offseason Roadblock as Mariners GM Pushes for $66M Reunion

Red Sox’s Patience With Alex Bregman Fades as D-Backs’ $116.5M Star Emerges as Backup Amid Blue Jays Buzz: Insider

Mets & David Stearns Forced to Battle Reds Threat as White Sox Ready to Let Go $50M Star

Dave Dombrowski emphasized that the new bullpen mix balances right-handed and left-handed options in high-leverage situations. “We like the overall mix of the bullpen,” he said, praising Keller as “one of the best in the business last year.”

Bowlan, who will make about $780,000 this season, is expected to gradually contribute from the right side, without immediately handling eighth or ninth-inning duties. Backus, at 27, offers further flexibility, having made 32 relief appearances last season with 22 strikeouts in 25 1/3 innings, providing options for multiple scenarios.

Philadelphia’s bullpen overhaul signals a clear strategy, showing Dombrowski’s hand is decisively calculated. The mix of Keller, Bowlan, and Backus reflects precise planning, not a gamble on chance or luck. Fans watching the moves can feel the balance shifting, as Philadelphia positions itself for high-leverage innings with purpose.