The familiar sights and sounds of baseball filled PNC Park on a late April evening. Fans cheered as the Pittsburgh Pirates faced the visiting Chicago Cubs. All at once, amid cheers, a terrible event shattered the night, silencing the crowd. Within seconds, the tragedy instantly shifted focus from the game to human life. It also inadvertently threw a harsh spotlight back on the team’s owner.

It occurred at the bottom of the seventh inning on April 30, 2025. Pirates poster boy Andrew McCutchen, with a go-ahead two-run double, sent the crowd into a frenzy. At that exact moment, a fan fell roughly 21 feet from the seating area above the Roberto Clemente Wall in right field. He hit the warning track below. Players on the field immediately stopped, waving frantically for medical help. McCutchen clutched the cross around his neck; others knelt in prayer, visibly distressed.

The following morning, May 1st, Pirates Chairman Bob Nutting reacted to the incident through the team’s official channels. His statement expressed profound sorrow over the “terrible accident.” Nutting shared, “We are all deeply saddened and truly heartbroken… It was one of the most difficult moments many of us have ever experienced.” He emphasized community, referring to Pirates fans as “like family” with pleas for support and prayer. Nutting also appropriately thanked the first responders for their “compassionate care” during the emergency.

Nutting’s words echoed sentiments shared by others closer to the field. Manager Derek Shelton, visibly shaken, made a few brief remarks after the game, offering thoughts and prayers while addressing only the fan and sending his thanks to the medical staff. He described the scene as “extremely unfortunate. That’s an understatement.” Andrew McCutchen also expressed his heavy heart on the internet: “Truly hate what happened tonight… Cant (sic) help but think about that guy, his family and friends.” He later stressed the importance of fans.

Beyond official statements: Pirates fanbase frustration surfaces

These official statements were filled with shock and sympathy and even gratitude – entirely appropriate, given the awfulness of what happened. They painted a picture of togetherness and care in the Pirates’ organization. However, the online public conversation among the fanbase quickly extended beyond these heartfelt words. The incident, tragically, became intertwined with long-simmering frustrations directed squarely at the team’s ownership.

The deep-seated skepticism towards Bob Nutting meant his official statement, however appropriate, landed differently among fans. “Wow Bob actually cared enough to say this…” This is a reaction that underscores the trust deficit that Nutting faces. Past incidents, like the Bucco Bricks controversy, where fans’ heartfelt memorials were tossed aside without much thought, contribute to this feeling.

For many Pirates fans, the desire for new ownership overshadows nearly everything that happens related to the team. “Tbh thought he was gonna announce he was selling the team bc the guy fell 😔”. This comment shows the deep-seated desire to see some new owners after years of frustration. Organized fan protests involving billboards demanding a sale, petitions with thousands of signatures, even loud chants at PNC Park, proved this wasn’t just some background distraction. The prevailing hope among the detractors is that something, anything, might finally force Nutting’s exit.

Some fans connected the team’s longstanding hardship under Nutting in a straight line to the tragic event itself. One fan roasted: “You made this team pathetic, Bob, he couldn’t stand it”. Too brutal? Well, it speaks volumes about fan anger. The Pirates have endured several 100-loss seasons and consistently boast one of MLB’s lowest payrolls. Seeing star players traded away adds to the perception that the owner is putting finances over producing a competitive team.

Naturally, the most common and enthusiastic response just repeated the age-old demand that has defined fan protests for years. The raw plea was seen repeatedly: “Sell the team Bob!! please just sell the team for the love of God sell the team!!!!!”. It reflects the belief held by a lot of people that sustained success is impossible under the current ownership. Surveys have even shown a large fraction of the fan base would accept the risk of relocation if it meant that Nutting would sell the team.

Lastly, the emotions and shock were so raw at the time that they mixed with an already boiling, subconscious hatred for the owners and led to some extreme reactions. “The team is killing people”. This statement, though not literal, likely channels grief and frustration into a powerful condemnation. It merges the specific tragedy with the larger sense that the team, under Bob Nutting, through its performance, perceived lack of care (like the Clemente sign removal), or general atmosphere, contributes to a sense of hopelessness or even danger associated with the franchise.

Do you think they should sell the Pirates? Let us know in the comments below.