In the age of NIL, where player compensation is often treated as untouchable, the Memphis Tigers head coach, Penny Hardaway, sent a message that reputation and valuation do not place anyone above team rules, and the fans are all for it.

During Memphis’ recent loss to the Vanderbilt Commodores, it was revealed on the broadcast that Hardaway had withheld portions of forward Aaron Bradshaw’s NIL compensation as a disciplinary measure, fining him $3,000 at a time for repeated violations of team rules.

The decision, while unconventional, was framed not as punishment for punishment’s sake, but as a calculated attempt to spark accountability inside a struggling Tigers locker room.

According to ESPN analyst Dane Bradshaw, the Memphis coach said he fined Bradshaw for showing up late and for violating the team’s dress code.

“I fined him for showing up late. I fined him for violating our dress code. Three grand here, three grand there,” the announcer said, quoting Penny Hardaway.  “Guess who started to show up early? Guess who started to put the effort in?”

As per The Daily Helmsman, Bradshaw was not formally “charged” money, but rather had funds withheld from his monthly NIL compensation, with more than $20,000 reportedly retained due to multiple infractions. Notably, those withheld funds weren’t pocketed by the program. Instead, the money is redistributed among teammates.

“(Penny Hardaway) takes that fine money and puts it back in the bucket and has some guys further down the roster reaping the cash benefit of those fines,” the analyst added.

Aaron Bradshaw, a former five-star McDonald’s All-American and the Tigers’ second-highest NIL earner behind Dug McDaniel, entered Memphis searching for consistency. Now, as a junior forward, after playing for Kentucky and Ohio State, the 7-footer is averaging 7.1 points and 2.9 rebounds in the ongoing 2025-26 NCAA season, while playing just over 15 minutes per game.

What made the decision by the head coach stand out wasn’t just the money involved, but the principle behind it and the basketball supports it!

Fans applaud Penny Hardaway’s approach in the NIL Era

NIL – short for Name, Image, and Likeness- allows college athletes to earn compensation through endorsements, appearances, and brand deals without jeopardizing their NCAA eligibility. Since its introduction, the model has sparked debate across college basketball.

While many view it as a long-overdue opportunity for athletes to profit from their brand, others argue it has disrupted team culture and accountability. Against that backdrop, Penny Hardaway’s decision struck a chord, with respect quickly pouring in from fans who saw it as a rare example of discipline in this era.

Top Stories

Fact Check: Were Greg Biffle & Family On the Plane That Crashed At Statesville, North Carolina?

Carlos Alcaraz’s Split With Coach Resulted From ‘Major Disagreements’ With His Father

“Rest in Peace”: Prayers Pour In From Dan Marino as Dolphins Legend Mourns Tragedy in South Florida Football

Who Is Greg Biffle’s Wife? Everything You Need to Know About Cristina Grossu

WNBA Responds to WNBPA Strike Authorization Vote With Official Statement

Footage Surfaces of Florida Police Arresting NASCAR Veteran Over Disturbing Public Misbehavior

“If nothing else will motivate em, that will. great coach,” one fan wrote. Another echoed the sentiment simply, adding, “I support this.”

Penny Hardaway, now in his eighth season as Memphis’ head coach, is no stranger to pressure or expectations around the program he once starred for as a player. But this season has presented early challenges. Memphis has already suffered six losses out of the ten games they have played, including defeats to ranked opponents like Purdue, Louisville, and Vanderbilt.

And then seeing an experienced, former five-star recruit struggle to produce, finishing with just three points in two games, is bound to test the patience of any coach.

Another fan focused on the financial aspect of the punishment, arguing that NIL money should not shield players from consequences. “Entirely fair. You want to be paid six or seven figures, you can start being fined.” Whereas another wrote, “W. Not that Aaron Bradshaw should have been receiving any money to play basketball to begin with.”

However, the debate around NIL’s long-term impact isn’t limited to college coaches or fans either. NBA legend Shaquille O’Neal previously raised similar concerns earlier this year on his podcast, questioning whether early financial comfort could dull a player’s competitive edge.

“NIL I think is definitely gonna hurt people,” Shaq said back in March. “For people that have nothing, when you get something, it takes the pressure off. But that something should be the final prize. The final prize should be the NBA. You give people like us who have nothing, sometimes it takes the edge off. You need that edge to keep climbing and climbing.”

A reaction from one more fan summed up the prevailing mood among supporters, as they wrote, “Accountability costs — he’ll learn 😂.”

However, whether this action by coach Penny Hardaway leads to a turnaround for Bradshaw or not remains to be seen.