Cutting a franchise icon like Cam Heyward once seemed impossible for the Pittsburgh Steelers, but a potential $14.3 million in cap savings is forcing a difficult conversation. Nothing is official, but Bleacher Report’s latest projection sees Heyward as a potential cut candidate.

“If the Steelers are resetting at quarterback and potentially entering somewhat of a rebuild, it might simply make sense to move on (from Heyward) at this stage,” Brad Gagnon of Bleacher Report wrote.

The Steelers are entering the 2026 season under new head coach Mike McCarthy, and a roster direction is being worked on. Quarterback questions, including Aaron Rodgers, are a separate discussion. On defense, though, Heyward has long been the centerpiece.

The veteran is under contract through 2026 and is set to earn $19.2 million that season. Releasing him would free up approximately $14.3 million in cap space, flexibility that could accelerate a transition if the franchise is leaning toward a reset.

Age is another factor. Heyward is 36, firmly in the latter stage of his career. Investing in a younger defensive tackle now would not only reduce future financial strain but also establish a long-term successor.

Production-wise, the picture is nuanced. He signed a two-year extension and remained heavily involved, with 78 combined tackles and nine tackles for loss, earning second-team All-Pro honors. Yet the overall impact showed signs of decline, with the numbers being nowhere near his 89 tackles in 2021.

All of it leaves Pittsburgh in a delicate spot. Bleacher Report’s prediction frames it as a shock. Whether it becomes reality will depend on how McCarthy ultimately defines the Steelers’ timeline for 2026 and beyond. What’s clear is that sooner rather than later, Pittsburgh must plan for life after Cam Heyward.

The Steelers have multiple options to replace Cam Heyward

Even though Cam Heyward is under contract for the 2026 season, he hasn’t publicly committed to playing beyond it. That uncertainty naturally forces the Steelers to think ahead. Pittsburgh has already been linked to multiple options. ‘Those possibilities range from developing young players to drafting upcoming prospects.

“Heyward turns 37 in May,” ESPN’s Brooke Prior noted. “While he’s under contract for another season, Heyward hasn’t announced a decision on his future. The Steelers have other young players in Keeanu Benton and 2025 fourth-round pick Yahya Black.”

Across a 15-year career in Pittsburgh, Heyward has anchored the defensive front, totaling 796 combined tackles and 142 tackles for loss. Whether through retirement or release, his departure would create a significant void.

That reality makes it reasonable for Mike McCarthy to begin mapping out a succession plan now rather than later.

At the center of that conversation is 24-year-old Keeanu Benton. Entering his fourth season, Benton has flashed potential but would need a noticeable leap under McCarthy to approximate Heyward’s impact.

Then there’s Derrick Harmon, last year’s first-round pick, who logged 12 regular-season games as a rookie and posted 27 tackles with three sacks. He profiles as a long-term piece if his development trends upward.

Yahya Black is another name in the mix. The 2025 fifth-round pick recorded 28 tackles in limited action during his rookie campaign and remains a developmental option along the interior.

Beyond the current roster, the draft offers another path. Some reports suggest Pittsburgh could consider Clemson defensive tackle Peter Woods with its first-round selection. The 20-year-old earned first-team All-ACC honors in 2025 after recording 30 tackles (10 solo), two sacks, 3.5 tackles for loss, and one defended pass.

It might raise eyebrows given the recent investment in Harmon, but pairing two young interior linemen could accelerate a defensive transition. Ultimately, whether McCarthy identifies Heyward’s successor from within the building or through the draft will unfold soon.