The trade of a superstar always sets off a whirlwind of chatter across the league. Juan Soto’s shift to the New York Mets has certainly been no exception. Viral clips and fan interpretations of his body language stoked speculation. Some skeptics questioned whether he was really committed to, or enthused about, his new team. But what is the true narrative brewing inside the Mets’ clubhouse?

The narrative of Soto possibly missing his old team, the Yankees, gained traction. This was based partly on his own candid confessions and observed differences. “It’s definitely different,” Soto acknowledged in April 2025, referring to the lineup. “I had the best hitter in baseball hitting behind me.” This was a clear nod to Aaron Judge. Fans also noted his famous rehearsed handshake with Judge after home runs, a comparison they made against the increasingly creative celebrations in Queens. These instances painted a picture, leaving many wondering if a piece of his heart remained in the Bronx.

But Metsmanager Carlos Mendoza has a very different perspective on his star outfielder. “He’s loving it, you know, like he’s super happy,” Mendoza said recently on WFAN Sports Radio. The manager added that he appreciated how Soto was taking things in stride. “Everything that you see in that locker room… he’s a smile. He’s always interacting.” This firm stance directly counters any recent doubts that have surrounded Soto’s dedication to the orange and blue, and his stand aims to clear the air.

And this isn’t even the first time Mendoza has publicly supported Soto’s transition. Prior to that, he praised how quickly the outfielder adapted to his new environment. “I didn’t think [the adjustment] was going to be this quick,” Mendoza had admitted. He also addressed Soto’s candid remarks about facing different pitching without Judge. “You were pretty honest, and before you know it, there’s a headline,” Mendoza noted, understanding his player’s straightforwardness. This consistent support suggests the team’s internal confidence in Soto.

The road ahead for Juan Soto

Results on the field often speak loudest, and Soto’s performance is trending positively. After a somewhat slow start, with a batting average below .250 and just three homers in his first 29 games, he has found his rhythm. As of May 17, 2025, Soto boasts a .255 batting average, 8 home runs, 20 RBIs, and an .845 OPS through 43 games. His initial .244 average over 23 games has climbed, showing he’s definitely getting back into his groove.

Meanwhile, across town, the team that let Soto go, the New York Yankees, has skillfully managed Soto’s absence. Newcomers like Cody Bellinger (.733 OPS and improving) and Trent Grisham (a fantastic .973 OPS) have stepped up significantly. Young talent Jasson Domínguez is also impressing, hitting .246 from the left side. The Bronx Bombers’ offense remains potent, with a .263 team batting average and 78 home runs, proving life continues after a star’s exit.

The discussion about Soto’s loyalty got fresh fuel during his recent return to Yankee Stadium. In the Subway Series opener on May 17, 2025, the Mets fell 6-2 to the Yankees. Soto faced a chorus of boos from the sellout crowd of 47,700, but he tipped his helmet respectfully. He went 0-for-4 in the game. After the game, Soto said, “I just enjoy (the booing). I don’t think it’s gonna affect me at all.”

In the end, perception and reality don’t always align in the high-stakes universe of pro sports. The rumors won’t go away, but Carlos Mendoza’s support and Soto’s big smile are good signs that he’s happy in a Mets uniform. The superstar outfielder clearly is heating up at the plate.

But the question remains: Can Juan Soto finally shut up the last of the haters and write a new history in Queens? Only time will tell.