
via Getty
(Photo by Mike Stobe/Getty Images)

via Getty
(Photo by Mike Stobe/Getty Images)
The New York Yankees sit in uncharted territory-this is not where Brian Cashman expected his all-star cast to be at the beginning of August. Well, you know what they say about the best-laid plans? The Yankees’ general manager went all-in at the trade deadline, making aggressive moves to salvage what has been an unexpectedly mediocre campaign. Instead of climbing the standings, the Bronx Bombers have been watching the unexpected surge of their rivals from the American League Central, overtaking them.
Cashman swung deals for David Bednar, Jake Bird, and Camilo Doval, transforming the bullpen with what appeared to be shrewd acquisitions. The Yankees also bolstered their lineup with José Caballero and Austin Slater, addressing defensive concerns and adding versatility to their roster. The front office acknowledged the team’s pressing needs after losing key rotation pieces from their World Series run. But despite these moves, the expected playoff push hasn’t materialized. Want to guess why? The moves simply haven’t translated to wins on the field.
“This has been almost 90 games as just a very average team.”
As of today, @Kurkjian_ESPN is leaning toward picking the Guardians to make the playoffs over the Yankees. pic.twitter.com/GAFyOdGSjt
— Foul Territory (@FoulTerritoryTV) August 11, 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
ESPN’s Tim Kurkjian delivered a stunning assessment that has Yankees fans questioning everything they thought they knew about this season. “I’m going to say right now, I don’t think they’re going to make the playoffs, and it came to me in the night that they’re playing so poorly right now,” Kurkjian declared.
AD
His brutal honesty didn’t stop there: “Even though Aaron Judge is back and he’s going to carry them, you just look at the other teams around them that are playing so much better than they are right now. So if you’re asking me who’s going to make the playoffs, the Guardians or the Yankees, I may have to say the Guardians.” The veteran analyst’s shock was palpable as he continued, “And I can’t believe I’m saying that because the Yankees always find a way to make the playoffs. But this has been almost 90 games as just a very average team.”
Despite the harsh criticism from analysts like Kurkjian, Cashman remains steadfast in defending his trade deadline approach. “We’ve improved the team, we believe. “Tried to address the areas of need,” Cashman said, defending his deadline strategy. “We added to the bullpen. We improved the position player group as well, giving the manager more choices to play matchups.” The GM remained confident in his acquisitions. But the on-field results tell a different story. TBH, it makes sense that questions are swirling around the organization’s direction when the improved roster hasn’t delivered improved wins.
Yankees Hit New Low as Boone Loses Cool Again
The New York Yankees’ woes intensified over the weekend as their problems extended beyond front office decisions to on-field execution. The Houston Astros delivered a crushing 7-1 defeat at Yankee Stadium on Sunday, exposing just how far this Yankees team has fallen from championship expectations. The loss represents more than just another defeat—it symbolizes the growing gap between where the Yankees thought they’d be and where they stand.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
Manager Aaron Boone’s frustrations boiled over in the third inning, resulting in his fifth ejection of the season following heated arguments with the home plate umpire over questionable ball and strike calls. Houston already had a commanding 2-0 lead when Boone lost his temper, setting a desperate tone for the rest of the game. The Astros had gotten their early goal against another slow offensive start by the Yankees: Jose Altuve had hit a solo home run while Christian Walker drove in a run with a double.
What’s your perspective on:
Is Aaron Boone's leadership the real issue behind the Yankees' lackluster performance this season?
Have an interesting take?

via Imago
Image credits: MLB.com
Despite the early confrontation that removed him from the dugout, Boone refused to use his ejection as an excuse for the team’s dismal performance. “It was the first couple of innings,” Boone explained to reporters after the game. “I was on him a lot. That’s over and done with, and it is what it is,indr and that isn’t the reason we lost this game.” The manager’s acknowledgment speaks volumes about a team struggling to find answers anywhere on the diamond.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
The Yankees wilted further to downhill at third place in the AL East. Now, the batsmen do astonishingly well to just hang on to the final Wild Card spot as they trail division-topping Toronto Blue Jays by 6.5 games. Away from clutching a wild card at the final moment, every game is going to be extremely important as the organization watches its postseason hopes slip away, making Cashman look worse with every defeat.
Top Stories
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
"Is Aaron Boone's leadership the real issue behind the Yankees' lackluster performance this season?"