The Titans’ 3-14 nightmare last season was supposed to end the moment they drafted Cam Ward. And to be fair, the No. 1 pick is already looking like the real deal. Alpha energy, laser throws, and the kind of leadership that has even ESPN’s Louis Riddick gushing: “He’s a master talker… holds everyone accountable. Legit.” For a franchise desperate to turn the page, Ward’s the perfect face of the new era. But here’s the problem: QBs – even the special ones – don’t fix broken teams alone.

And while Ward’s been saying all the right things, the Titans’ offseason moves might be saying something else entirely. Behind the glowing reports about their rookie QB, there’s a quieter, less optimistic reality taking shape – one that could test Ward’s golden-boy hype faster than anyone expected. For all the hype around Ward’s leadership and arm talent, the Titans might already be setting him up to fail. Sure, landing a franchise QB at No. 1 was the easy part, but look at what they’ve done (or haven’t done) since.

Their big free-agent splashes? Tackle Dan Moore Jr. (67.2 PFF grade in Pittsburgh) and LB Cody Barton (63.7 in Denver) – solid role players, but hardly game-changers. The draft? Outside of Ward, it was a rollercoaster of questionable value picks that left analysts scratching their heads. Dig deeper, and the deals look even riskier:

• Moore allowed 5 sacks and 35 pressures last season—fine for a backup, shaky for an $82 million ‘solution’
• Barton whiffed on 14% of tackles and got torched in coverage (98.7 QB rating against), as per PFF

Translation: Tennessee’s ‘redemption arc’ is leaning heavily on Ward to be a Day 1 miracle worker. No elite pass protector. No surefire WR1. Just a rookie QB expected to elevate a roster that, by most measures, didn’t get meaningfully better this offseason. And for a guy who’s never taken an NFL snap, that’s a brutal ask, no matter how ‘alpha’ he is.

The curious case of Brian Callahan’s roster grade

There’s a strange dissonance in how some analysts have graded Brian Callahan’s roster overhaul, some giving a standing ovation for a play that hasn’t even premiered yet. Yes, Cam Ward is the kind of quarterback you build around for a decade, but the Titans’ supporting cast? It’s a patchwork quilt of question marks, rehab projects, and outright gambles. So PFF’s C+ grading for their 2025 offseason ultimately feels about right.

Take their draft beyond Ward. Safety Kevin Winston Jr. (Round 3) is coming off a torn ACL – a raw talent who might contribute against the run but could get exposed in coverage. Receiver Chimere Dike (Round 4) has the measurables but needs to refine his routes, meaning he’s unlikely to be an immediate difference-maker. These aren’t bad picks, necessarily, but they’re developmental players being asked to contribute faster than they might be ready for.

Then there’s free agency. Van Jefferson, signed to replace Nick Westbrook-Ikhine’s production, hauled in just 24 passes for 276 yards last season – hardly the kind of numbers that inspire confidence. And Brandon Allen? A career third-string QB whose signing feels more like a training camp formality than a strategic move.

Callahan has talked up these additions as “high-upside pieces,” but the reality is, the Titans didn’t do enough to ensure Ward has a functional ecosystem around him. The offensive line, outside of JC Latham’s risky transition to left tackle, didn’t get the reinforcements it needed. And the defense, while improved in spots, still has holes that could force Ward into shootouts he’s not ready for.

So when analysts slap a C+ grade on this roster, they are (perhaps rightly) predicting trouble ahead for the No. 1 pick. The Titans didn’t just bet on Cam Ward. They bet that he could carry a team still riddled with ‘ifs’. And if that’s the case, Callahan’s offseason business might be facing a serious reality check by mid-season.