

“You know, it’s interesting. When I started catching some wind of this, it was catching some speed last night around about 11PM…” Jane Slater’s voice crackles like static on a vintage radio, her words dripping with the kind of drama usually reserved for Scandal’s Olivia Pope. But this isn’t D.C.—it’s Dallas, baby. And the Cowboys just pulled off a move slicker than a Tony Romo no-look pass, trading for Steelers’ mercurial wideout George Pickens. At 24, with 2,841 career yards and a highlight reel that screams ‘YouTube algorithm’s favorite child,’ Pickens is now Jerry Jones’ latest shiny toy. But why?
Because in Big D, they’ve got a type: big-bodied, big-ego receivers who need someone to whisper, ‘It’s gonna be okay,’ into their helmets. Enter Brian Schottenheimer, the Cowboys’ new head coach and resident Zen master. Because if Dez Bryant taught us anything, it’s this: Talented divas need communicators, not just playbooks.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
The Cowboys’ calculated chaos
Let’s start with Jerry Jones, sipping Johnny Walker Blue like he’s Don Draper closing a deal. “I gotta imagine Jerry’s enjoying his Johnny Walker Blues somewhere as he celebrates this,” Slater smirks. The Cowboys didn’t just land Pickens—they landed a walking ‘math problem’ for defenses. “He adds an explosive element… someone will get extra attention, which means someone else will capitalize,” Slater explains, her source texting poetry in a league of spreadsheets.
In Big D, Pickens won’t be the lone exhibit. Opposite CeeDee Lamb, he’ll draw doubles, he’ll puzzle secondaries, he’ll echo Dez’s red-zone prowess. Last season’s 900 yds and three TDs were just the trailer; now the feature begins. Schottenheimer will be there every step—film room pep talks, midweek check-ins, ‘You got this’ man-to-man.
Pickens and Bryant share a need for stellar communicators. “Now one of the questions,” Slater noted, pausing, “and to tie this back in with what you said there, Tom—well, I thought Brian Schottenheimer was all about the culture. Well, let’s get into that with George Pickens.” Schotty’s knack for sending clear signals is exactly what 24-year-old Pickens needs to turn that raw talent into elite production.
Dallas’ front office deserves props: no wild splashes, no cap carnage—just a pinpoint trade that feels tailor-made. Pair Pickens with CeeDee Lamb? That’s not a receiver room—it’s a fireworks show. Add KaVontae Turpin’s jet-fueled speed and rookie Jaden Blue’s potential? Suddenly, Dak Prescott’s got more weapons than a ‘John Wick’ sequel.But this isn’t just about stats. It’s about fixing what broke. Remember 2024? Seven wins, a defense leakier than a screen door on a submarine, and a locker room vibe colder than Lambeau in December. “The issue… was you could definitely feel like some of the chemistry was off,” Slater admits.
Wake up fans! Jerry Jones and the Cowboys are moving different. Some more details about why I think this is crazy enough to work from tonight’s The Insiders. Jerry is likely celebrating somewhere with his Johnny Walker Blue.
A few other notes… they are not extending or… pic.twitter.com/NFiSQiZZvl— Jane Slater (@SlaterNFL) May 7, 2025
What’s your perspective on:
Can George Pickens become the next Dez Bryant, or will his antics overshadow his talent in Dallas?
Have an interesting take?
Schottenheimer’s job? Rebuild that culture like he’s hosting ‘Fixer Upper’. “Yes, he’s a really great communicator,” she stresses. And for guys like Pickens—or Dez, who once snarled, “Throw up the X!” after every TD—that’s gospel, and suddenly you realize Pickens and Bryant both flourish when the message is crystal as he is deemed to be a really affable coach.
Schottenheimer’s secret sauce? Maturity meets motivation. “There needs to be some maturation here,” Slater says of Pickens. “He wants the ball—no different than a lot of wide receivers.” In Pittsburgh, he had Justin Fields and Russell Wilson tossing him pigskins. But now they’re both gone, replaced with Mason Rudolph and an Aaron Rodgers shaped question mark. In Dallas? It’s Prescott, a QB who’s thrown for 31,437 yards and knows how to handle alpha personalities. “We are talking about a little bit of a different quarterback here,” Slater winks. Translation: Pickens won’t need to play hero ball anymore. Just catch, run, and let Schotty handle the rest.
So here we are: Pickens, the prodigal receiver, heading to a city where communicators reign. Dez Bryant needed that same stewardship; Pickens does too. Under Schotty’s watch, this might not just be a reboot—it could be a whole new blockbuster.
Tomlin’s tough love post Pickens
Now flip the script to Pittsburgh, where Mike Tomlin’s steely gaze could melt steel beams. “He’s gotta grow up,” Tomlin growled last December after Pickens racked up unsportsmanlike flags against Cincinnati. Those words weren’t just criticism—they were a prophecy. By May, Tomlin was done. “From everything I’ve heard, Mike Tomlin was the one that was in front of this all,” Mark Kaboly revealed. Not ownership. Not the GM. Tomlin had his limit.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad

via Imago
Credits: IMAGO
Pickens’ Steelers tenure was a rollercoaster. The highs? A Thanksgiving dinner at Tomlin’s house, bonding over turkey and play-action schemes. The lows? Fines for eye-black messages, ejections, and sideline meltdowns. Through it all, Tomlin played mentor and drill sergeant. “He had a great relationship with the guys in the locker room and his quarterbacks,” Slater notes. But talent can’t trump tantrums forever. When Pickens’ antics overshadowed his 1,140-yard 2023 season, Tomlin did what he does best: cut the noise.
Trading Pickens wasn’t just a roster move—it was a cultural reset. In comes D.K. Metcalf, all muscle and menace, to pair with Pat Freiermuth. Out goes the drama. “They’ve made some really smart, selectively aggressive moves,” Slater says of Dallas. But in Pittsburgh? It’s about reclaiming identity. Tomlin’s Steelers don’t do divas. They do discipline. And if that means shipping out a star to protect the locker room?
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
There’s a beauty here, y’all. In Dallas, they’re betting on redemption—on Schottenheimer’s calm to tame Pickens’ storm. In Pittsburgh, they’re doubling down on grit. It’s one team building a future, another guarding a legacy. And Pickens? He’s got 12 months to prove he’s more than a viral catch. To show he can be Dez 2.0 without the sideline fireworks. Because in the NFL, potential is just a word until you pair it with purpose. As they say ‘You can’t cook from the living room.’ Grab your popcorn. This season’s about to sizzle
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Can George Pickens become the next Dez Bryant, or will his antics overshadow his talent in Dallas?